Columns

50% less traffic, 75% less money. Three sites hit by Google updates sold, stayed, or came back

Traffic drop at two of the sites
−50%
Profit or income drop at the same two sites
−75%
Gadgeneko revenue in the year pageviews rose 1.75x
×2

After a Google update, Fin vs Fin lost about half its search traffic and 75% of its profit. Charleston Crafted lost about half its total traffic and 75% of its income. The mechanisms differed, yet the multiplier was the same. Gadgeneko went the other way, with pageviews up 1.75x and revenue doubling. The three sites split three ways: sell, stay, come back.

By the Small Start editorial desk. We count every case in the archive by hand. The figures belong to the sources. The judgments are ours.

50% less traffic, 75% less money. Three sites hit by Google updates sold, stayed, or came back
Reader

If a Google update cuts your traffic in half, does your income just drop by half too?

It didn’t. At least not for the two sites lined up here.

I was reading the Fin vs Fin case and the Charleston Crafted case back to back, and I stopped when the same numbers showed up a second time.

What you'll learn
  • Two sites where traffic halved and what was left in hand fell to a quarter
  • Why the two sites got to a quarter for different reasons
  • Gadgeneko, where the same shape ran in reverse: pageviews 1.75x, revenue 2x
  • What split the three into selling, staying, and coming back
  • Why owning more sites wasn't diversification

Fin vs Fin, a comparison site for wellness products, lost about half its search traffic to Google’s Helpful Content Update. Its revenue halved and its profit fell 75%.

Charleston Crafted, a DIY blog, lost 96% of its traffic from Google. Since Google had supplied about half its visitors, total traffic fell by about half. Its income dropped 75%.

One counts profit and the other counts income, so they aren’t measuring the same thing.

Still, the shape matches: when traffic halved, what was left in hand fell to a quarter.

The two sites ended up at a quarter for different reasons. And the same shape also appeared in reverse.

Gadgeneko, a gadget blog, fell in a core update. Within a year it climbed back from 40,000 to 70,000 monthly pageviews, and its monthly revenue went from about ¥30,000 to about ¥60,000. Pageviews rose 1.75x and revenue doubled.

Search traffic doesn’t act on revenue one-for-one.

Here the three sites go into the same frame. What fell, why the fall grew larger, and what each chose after the fall. The three took separate roads: one sold, one stayed, one came back.

Sold, stayed, came back

SiteWhat fellWhy the fall grew largerWhat it chose afterward
Fin vs FinSearch traffic down about 50%, revenue down 50%, profit down 75%Costs that do not move when traffic drops, such as payments to contractorsSold in March 2024 for 3x its reduced annual profit
Charleston CraftedGoogle traffic down 96%, total traffic down about 50%, income down 75%The readers it lost were search readers, worth the most in ad and link revenueKept publishing four posts a week and expanded into Pinterest, Instagram, and PDF sales
GadgenekoTraffic fell in the October 2023 core update(On the way back, too, revenue moved more than pageviews)Changed domains and kept publishing once a week. The recovery came from Google Discover and Google News

The three differ in country and in size.

Before the hit, Fin vs Fin had $1M in annual revenue and $70,000 in monthly profit. Charleston Crafted had 2023 revenue of $300,000 to $500,000. Gadgeneko is a personal blog making ¥60,000 a month.

What they share is only this: most of their revenue was entrusted to search, and they took an update that happened on the search side.

Profit fell faster than traffic because costs didn’t fall

80% of Fin vs Fin’s traffic came from search.

The main site drew about 30,000 monthly visits, and all five sites together drew about 50,000. That modest traffic was turned into $1M a year through affiliate deals with more than 300 partner brands.

The business was run by the founder and five contractors covering VA work, development, design, editing, and writing.

  1. Search traffic halves

    The update cut search traffic by about half.

  2. Revenue roughly halves

    Revenue fell by about the same margin as traffic.

  3. Costs stay put

    Contractor payments don't shrink along with traffic.

  4. Profit falls 75%

    If revenue halves and costs stay, profit is cut far more than revenue.

That’s what the 75% drop consists of.

Income fell faster than traffic because the lost readers were worth more

On the Charleston Crafted side, there’s no story of large fixed costs like Fin vs Fin’s. It was run by a married couple.

Even so, against a halving of traffic, income fell 75%.

The difference lies in which readers were lost.

Readers who arrive from search open an article because they have a task to look up, then see ads and click links.

As the Charleston Crafted case describes, traffic fell 70% over the three months from March to May 2024, and display ad income fell 65%.

Our reading is that income dropped to a quarter while traffic only halved because the half that remained open their wallets far less than the half that was lost.

What didn't work
  • Pinterest traffic to Charleston Crafted's main site rose 200%, and the second site grew to more than 10 times the previous year
  • The husband's Instagram account reached 48,000 followers in a few months
  • The PDF products sell several thousand dollars a month

All that growth in the same period, and income still stayed 75% down.

The channels that grew didn’t bring readers worth as much as the ones from the channel that was lost.

On the way back, revenue also moved more than pageviews

Gadgeneko didn’t keep detailed numbers on the fall. What remains are numbers on the recovery.

Traffic fell in the October 2023 core update, and the domain changed in August 2024.

The fifth-year report (February 2025) shows around 40,000 monthly pageviews and about ¥30,000 a month. The sixth-year report (February 2026) shows about 70,000 monthly pageviews and about ¥60,000 a month.

In the year pageviews rose 1.75x, revenue doubled.

The author writes that the growth was “all thanks to the great Google.”

Placements in Discover, placements in Google News, and top search rankings all increased, and reviews of new products were read heavily all at once. The traffic that came back came from the same Google that had taken it away.

Put the three side by side and search traffic turns out to act on revenue with a multiplier.

On the way down, it shrinks revenue sharply, through costs that don’t move or through the high value of the readers lost. On the way up, revenue also grows more than pageviews.

Revenue entrusted to search gets paid back multiplier and all.

The multiple could be protected, the number it multiplies could not

Of the choices made after the fall, Fin vs Fin’s has the clearest numbers.

At the end of 2023 it began a sale through the broker Quiet Light and collected 10 letters of intent in three weeks. It sold in March 2024 for 3x its reduced annual profit, a seven-figure dollar sum.

The discount from the first offer was held to 15%. The buyer was a small family office using an SBA loan, the US government-backed loan for small businesses.

The 3x multiple held, in line with the going rate for sites of this size.

What didn’t hold was the profit that 3x was applied to. It had fallen 75% from the pre-hit $70,000 a month.

The loss in value showed up in the number being multiplied, not in the multiple.

This brings me back to a view we’ve been writing for a while.

The speed of an exit measures the speed of a decision, not the size of a failure.

Fin vs Fin sold after the fall, and the price was set by the profit after the fall.

The opposite example is 10Beasts, an eight-article Amazon affiliate site that sold for $570,000. A Google penalty arrived 17 days after the handover.

The site that fell was the one the buyer now owned, and the buyer removed the offending links and recovered its rankings in about five days.

That 10Beasts timed its sale well is hindsight. What the numbers do show is that a decision to sell commands a high price only before the fall.

Four sites weren’t diversification

Besides its main site, Charleston Crafted owned three other sites, covering crafts for kids, paint color reviews, and how to grow plants.

The topics were separate, but every one of them got its traffic from Google search.

  1. The September 2023 update

    The three spin-off sites lost 75% of their traffic.

  2. December

    The main site began falling.

  3. The March 2024 update

    The main site fell further.

Adding sites, with only one source of traffic, just staggered the timing of the falls a little.

Fin vs Fin also owned five sites, but when it sold, the number of sites wasn’t what held up the price.

In the third month of due diligence, the buyer asked for a price cut citing the traffic decline. The seller answered with its profit records and with assets a buyer could take over, namely partnerships with more than 300 brands.

Search rankings can’t be handed over. Partnership contracts can.

The three cases chosen, and where the numbers come from

These three were chosen from published cases where the article states the site took a Google update and the size of the fall or the recovery can be read in numbers.

They were picked so that the three roads of selling, staying, and coming back each have one case, so they can’t be called representative of sites that depend on search. No median is given either.

Where the numbers come from

Fin vs Fin's figures come from the founder's account in a single article about the sale. Charleston Crafted's come from the owner's interview and several news reports, and monthly figures and ad rates aren't public. Gadgeneko's come from the author's yearly reports, and there are no pageview or revenue figures from the time of the fall. In "half the traffic, a quarter in hand," Fin vs Fin counts profit and Charleston Crafted counts income, so the comparison isn't like for like.

The biggest bias lies in the records that don’t exist.

Many sites that fell in an update and then shut down left without ever writing down how far they fell. The people lined up here are the ones who still had a reason to write after the fall.

The gap between pageviews and revenue itself is counted in separate columns. In the one that counted why businesses closed, platform change also ranks near the top.

The options left after the fall were decided before it

Having lined up the three sites, we think what the updates measured wasn’t article quality.

About a month before it fell in an update, Charleston Crafted had been filmed as a subject for a Google ad.

What was being measured was how much of a site’s revenue was borrowed from search, and at what multiplier.

After the fall, each of the three had different roads open to it.

Editors

Some of this is speculation. Fin vs Fin could sell because transferable partnerships and a buyer able to pay with a government-backed loan were there first. Charleston Crafted could stay because, run by a couple, it had the time to grow other channels. Gadgeneko could wait because it was a ¥60,000-a-month blog whose author had set the conditions for continuing as "not going into the red, and not getting bored."

None of these roads was chosen on the day the update arrived.

Each was chosen from among things built before it.

If this one impressed you

This column is the editorial desk's own reading of the cases published on Small Start (all public information, all sourced) and of other public information. It is not a recommendation of any particular business, investment or side venture.

Read more columns →

Sources

This article summarizes and analyzes the public sources above. Please refer to the primary sources for details.

You may freely quote or republish this article in news media, blogs, or AI answers, provided you credit "Small Start (small-start.com)" and link to this page. No prior permission is needed. Reprint & quotation policy →
Found this useful? Share it
Share on X