Operating

Charleston Crafted lost 96% of its Google traffic

The DIY blog Charleston Crafted turned over $300,000 to $500,000 in 2023 on roughly 250,000 monthly pageviews. After Google updates starting in September 2023, search traffic fell 96%, the smaller sites fell 99%, and income dropped 75% in a year. In March 2024 the owner posed for a Google ad.

Charleston Crafted lost 96% of its Google traffic
Reader

Sites that crash after a search update are the thin ones, right? If you do good work, aren't you safe?

Here’s a case where that explanation doesn’t hold. Google itself had picked this site for its ads.

What you'll learn
  • The order in which a couple's DIY blog lost its traffic right after appearing in a Google ad
  • Why traffic fell by roughly 50% while income fell 75%
  • What was said in the room at Google's Creator Summit
  • What Pinterest and Instagram gave back, and the hole they couldn't fill
  • Why four sites didn't add up to diversification, and the limits of the numbers

In 2023, Charleston Crafted took in $300,000 to $500,000 on roughly 250,000 pageviews a month.

A year later, in the words of owner Morgan McBride, it had become “my income is down by 75% this year, and our Google traffic is down by 99% on our smaller sites, and down by 96% on CharlestonCrafted.”

Sites that fall out of search are usually explained away as thin or mass-produced.

This couple’s site was neither.

During the same stretch, Google picked them as advertising material.

In March 2024 McBride posed for Google ad photos in her half-renovated kitchen.

According to PPC Land’s write-up of Bloomberg’s reporting, Google traffic had fallen more than 70% by the time the ad ran about a month later.

What happened, and in what order

PeriodEvent or figure
2012Morgan McBride and Sean McBride start a DIY blog
2016A DIY conference in Atlanta prompts a change of direction
July 2018Joins the ad network Mediavine. Morgan goes full time the same year
2020Sean goes full time. Three further sites launch and are monetised within six months
Before the fall2M+ annual pageviews, ~200,000 monthly, ad revenue up 80% over three years (per Google for Publishers)
2023Revenue of $300,000 to $500,000, roughly 250,000 monthly pageviews
September 2023Helpful Content Update. The three spinoff sites lose 75% of their traffic
December 2023The main site is hit and traffic starts sliding
March 2024Core update. Traffic down 70% and display ad revenue down 65% between March and May
August 2024Another drop
October 2024Attends Google’s Creator Summit
November 2024“Income down 75%, Google traffic down 99% on the small sites, 96% on the main one”

The three spinoffs are Celebrating With Kids for children’s activities and crafts, Paint Color Project for paint colour reviews, and Keep Your Plants Alive for indoor and outdoor plant care.

The About page says the couple run everything themselves, through The Charleston Crafted Blog LLC in South Carolina.

The photo shoot in March, the traffic gone in April

Google’s own case page shows them before the fall.

More than two million annual pageviews, ad revenue up 80% over three years, three extra sites monetised in six months.

Sean is quoted saying that ad revenue gave them financial security and the freedom to be entrepreneurs. They were on display as a success story for the ad business.

A site chosen as a poster case lost 96% to an update by the same company.

That sequence tends to get consumed as irony. Our editors read a design problem in it.

To Google they were a usable example of a high-quality independent publisher.

Quality assessment and search treatment were running on separate tracks inside one company.

The explanation that they fell because the content had a problem doesn’t hold up here.

Traffic halved, income quartered

The breakdown carries the meaning.

In the Niche Pursuits interview, McBride says Google was about half of total traffic.

That half dropped 96%, so site-wide traffic fell by roughly 50%.

Income fell 75%.

When traffic halves and income drops to a quarter, what went missing was unit value rather than volume.

A reader arriving from search has a job to do, opens the guide, sees the ads, clicks the affiliate link. A reader arriving from social behaves differently.

AdExchanger reports that traffic fell 70% and display ad revenue 65% across March to May 2024.

Editors

This next part is inference on our side: income kept falling faster than traffic because of how much more each search visit was worth.

Losing Google didn’t mean losing half the readers.

It meant losing the audience that set the price of the ad inventory.

The room where she was told her content was good

In October 2024 McBride was invited to Google’s Creator Summit.

Her account in Niche Pursuits is blunt. The mood in the room “felt very like a funeral.”

Engineers told her “your content is good, we know your content is good.”

Search VP Pandu Nayak, per MediaPost, largely denied that the update had the effect creators described. Danny Sullivan’s line that “September traffic is not coming back” also circulated.

McBride’s own reading: “They can’t fix their algorithm, they have to just make big changes.”

Earlier algorithm swings had come and gone, and each time she adjusted the site and recovered. This one hasn’t come back.

With no target to repair, more than a year passed in which repairs produced nothing.

What didn't work
  • Adjusting the site to win traffic back, as she had after earlier swings. This time no target to repair was ever named

That’s the shape of the failed-tactics section here. It records not a tactic that failed but a situation where no tactic could be defined.

What the remaining channels returned

In the same interview McBride cites the numbers that moved.

What worked
  • Pinterest traffic is up 200% on the main site and more than 10x year over year on the second site
  • Her husband's Instagram account reached 48,000 followers within months
  • Digital PDF products sell several thousand dollars a month
  • Publishing holds at four articles a week

None of it fills the hole in a $300,000 to $500,000 year. Income remains down 75%.

What she offered other creators was one line, “you did it once, you can do it again.” That’s not a recovery plan.

What broke here was the assumption that the income could be forecast, rather than the income itself.

Four sites fell to the same updates, and revenue survives only as a band

Owning four sites didn’t amount to diversification.

The three spin-offs and the main site all drew their traffic from Google search. They took the same company’s updates in turn, in September and December 2023 and again in March 2024.

Adding sites with a single traffic source only staggered the dates on which they fell.

Other businesses have had search updates cut deep. Here they are, ordered by the figures we can see.

Fin vs Fin pairs with Charleston Crafted directly, taking the same 75% decline toward an exit.

A note on the numbers

Every figure here comes from reporting and interviews, with no monthly actuals, ad RPM or per-site breakdown made public. Annual revenue exists only as the $300,000 to $500,000 band, and whether that covers four sites or one is never stated.

The case was still being cited in AdExchanger in January 2026 under both the algorithm-update and the AI-search framing.

No number from the operators separates one effect from the other.

If this one impressed you

Similar cases

Sources

This article summarizes and analyzes the public sources above. Please refer to the primary sources for details.
You may freely quote or republish this article in news media, blogs, or AI answers, provided you credit "Small Start (small-start.com)" and link to this page. No prior permission is needed. Reprint & quotation policy →
Found this useful? Share it
Share on X