Operating

Oh Dear: $1M ARR, two founders, zero employees

Mattias Geniar and Freek Van der Herten started this website monitoring SaaS as a side project in 2017. Eight years later it passed $1M ARR with no employees and no funding, still just the two of them. Day one brought about 20 paying users from a 500-person list and roughly $1,500 in monthly revenue.

Oh Dear: $1M ARR, two founders, zero employees
Reader

If you've been blogging and speaking for twenty years, shouldn't finding customers be easy? So why spend money on ads at all?

The founder’s own answer points the other way.

What you'll learn
  • The timeline from a side project to $1M ARR, still two people with no employees and no funding
  • Why skipping a free tier was an accounting decision
  • How the founder rates Google Ads, paid SEO articles and Reddit Ads
  • What actually brought in the first 20 paying customers
  • Which numbers are missing, and where each source stands

As of September 2025, Oh Dear is above $83K a month and past $1M ARR.

Eight years in, there are no employees and no outside capital. The same two people still run it.

For a developer with twenty years of audience behind him, finding buyers ought to be a solved problem.

Yet in a 2026 interview, Mattias Geniar was asked what the hardest part of the business has been. He answered “distribution, hands down.”

He added that “even at $1M ARR, distribution is our biggest challenge.”

In the same interview, his single biggest regret was every dollar they put into paid advertising.

They sold to a 500-person list without quitting their jobs

WhenEventNumbers
Around 2017Both keep their day jobs and build in evenings and weekendsNeither quit anything
2018Launch, announced to a list built by posting screenshots and code on TwitterList of about 500, about 10% converted. Nearly 20 paying users on day one, around $1,500 monthly
2019Status pages shipped, adopted by status.laravel.com among others“We managed to double our MRR in 2019” (cofounder’s blog)
September 2025Indie Hackers interviewAbove $83K a month, $1M ARR, two people
April 2026SaaSRat interview$1M+ ARR, zero employees, $0 raised, over a million monitoring jobs daily

Geniar was a sysadmin at a managed hosting provider. Van der Herten was a partner at a web agency.

Two failures got them started.

  1. An SSL certificate expires

    You hear about it from the customer, not from your monitoring.

  2. Internal links break

    A deployment breaks 200 internal links, and nobody notices for weeks.

  3. A crawler that follows every link

    The differentiator in version one was a crawler that follows every link on a site the way a search engine would.

Existing tools, Geniar says, “just ping your homepage and tell you it’s up. That’s maybe 10% of what can actually go wrong with a website.”

He describes the growth curve himself: “Slow. Very slow for years, then it picked up.”

The only checkpoint with independent backing is the 2019 doubling. Nothing between that and the $83K of 2025 has been published.

No free tier, because free users cost money

Pricing has ten steps, decided by one variable: the number of sites monitored.

Solo covers 2 sites at $17 a month. Scale covers 200 at $439, and anything above that is quoted individually.

No feature is held back for higher tiers, and users are unlimited.

The only way in is a 10-day trial. Annual billing takes two months off.

The reason he gives is cost of goods.

“Free users cost money and rarely convert. Every monitor we run uses server resources, bandwidth, and storage. If someone isn’t willing to pay after trying the product, they probably weren’t going to pay at month six either.”

Flat features also help conversion, he argues, “because people don’t have to figure out which plan they need.”

Here’s how we’d read that design.

Dropping the free tier was an accounting decision, not a philosophical one.

Variable cost in monitoring scales with checks executed, not with headcount. So a free user starts piling up cost the moment they sign up, in a straight line.

If you’re running over a million jobs a day, a free tier stops being a place where people put up with fewer features and becomes a place where people use the same servers without an invoice.

Tally, also two people in Belgium, gives away 99% of its features and reached $150K MRR in four years. But form building carries a cost per submission that’s orders of magnitude lighter.

All three ad channels missed, and the credit went to “building in public”

The paid channels have no disclosed spend, but the verdicts are clear.

ChannelHis assessment
Google Ads“We spent a ton on Google Ads. It made no meaningful difference.” The monitoring market is saturated, and clicks converted badly because people clicking ads are still researching rather than buying
Paid SEO articles“Most of them were garbage.” Developers and DevOps people “can smell outsourced marketing copy from a mile away”
Reddit Ads“The least bad of the bunch.” Some traction, “still nothing compared to organic word of mouth”
What didn't work
  • Google Ads, in a saturated market where clicks came from people still researching
  • Paid SEO articles, which developers spotted as outsourced copy
  • Reddit Ads, the least bad, still far behind organic word of mouth

Asked about regrets, he answered like this.

“The money we spent on paid advertising. Every dollar we put into Google Ads and outsourced content would have been better spent on literally anything else. Conference sponsorships, design improvements, even taking a week off.”

So what did work?

His answer is “building in public. Full stop.” The SaaSRat piece closes on that note too.

Our reading differs.

What brought in those 20 customers and $1,500 on day one wasn’t eight years of building Oh Dear in public. It was the balance built up before any of that.

He says as much in the same answer: “Freek and I both had around 20 years of online presence before Oh Dear existed. We’d been blogging, tweeting, speaking at conferences, and contributing to open source for decades.”

What paid off was the twenty years of balance behind those eight years in public.

The distinction matters in practice.

Anyone can start working in the open today. Whether that turns into 20 paid signups on launch day depends on how much trust was banked beforehand.

That’s why his advice to founders without an audience is simply to start building one now.

Editors

Speculating from here: we don't think market saturation was the real reason paid ads failed either. Compared with an entry route made of recommendations from people who already knew them, ad traffic arrives judging the same product by completely different criteria.

At $1M ARR, distribution is still the hard part

The split between them is clean.

Geniar handles support, admin, monitoring-related development and proofs of concept. Van der Herten does core PHP work, refactoring and the crawler.

Hiring has been considered for eight years and never done. “Adding employees changes everything. Payroll, management, communication overhead, legal obligations.”

The stack is deliberately dull.

Laravel, PHP, MySQL, Redis and ClickHouse for analytics. Bare metal for dispatch, and about 50 VMs across DigitalOcean, Vultr and AWS for global coverage.

“When your entire product is about reliability and uptime, the last thing you want is a bleeding-edge stack that introduces instability.”

The heaviest line lands in the quick-fire round.

Asked for his best business decision, Geniar said: “Not going solo.”

“Having a co-founder kept us accountable through the slow years. When I was burned out, Freek pushed forward. When he was burned out, I did. A solo founder in our position would have quit by year three.”

What worked
  • Around 20 years of online presence each, built before Oh Dear existed
  • A price list with no free tier and every feature in every plan
  • Two founders, so one could push forward while the other was burned out

The first thing this founder names as the cause of a $1M ARR business is neither a feature, a price nor a channel.

It’s the fact that neither of them quit. That’s worth recording.

The undisclosed numbers, and where the sources stand

What we couldn't verify

Customer count, churn, profit, actual ad spend and the trajectory from 2019 to 2025 are all unpublished. The $1M ARR figure is self-reported and unaudited. A scale number exists in the form of a million monitoring jobs a day, but how many companies or sites that corresponds to doesn't.

The sources deserve labels too.

The most detailed one, SaaSRat, is a software comparison site publishing on its own blog. A plug for that site sits inside the interview.

The Indie Hackers article is paywalled. Only the figures visible in its free opening are used here.

The 2019 doubling is the one data point that comes firsthand, from a cofounder’s own blog. The rest of the path rests on secondary reporting.

A Laravel community, and a 2017 start

Instatus reached $48K MRR on status pages alone. Oh Dear sits at $83K a month. Plausible hit $1M ARR with four people and zero ad spend.

All three stayed almost entirely off paid advertising and circulated by name inside developer communities.

Even among them, Oh Dear stands on conditions that are hard to put together after the fact.

Laravel and PHP form a sharply defined community. One cofounder is a widely known open source developer inside that ecosystem. And monitoring is the kind of tool nobody removes once it’s installed.

Starting in 2017, before price competition in monitoring reached today’s level, isn’t a neutral detail either.

One more thing. With churn undisclosed, there’s no way from outside to tell how much of that $83K is being refilled by new business every month.

If this one impressed you

Similar cases

Sources

This article summarizes and analyzes the public sources above. Please refer to the primary sources for details.
You may freely quote or republish this article in news media, blogs, or AI answers, provided you credit "Small Start (small-start.com)" and link to this page. No prior permission is needed. Reprint & quotation policy →
Found this useful? Share it
Share on X