Operating

Darknet Diaries: 4,457 Paying Members, $15,000 a Month, and Why an 18.5M-Download Podcast Hides Ad Revenue but Publishes Stats

Cybercrime podcast Darknet Diaries earns nearly $15,000 a month from 4,457 paying members. Ads are capped at two 60-second slots per episode, with revenue undisclosed. The official stats page publishes annual downloads including the drop from a 27.7M peak in 2022 to 18.5M in 2023. A look at the verifiable floor beneath a solo audio business.

Darknet Diaries: 4,457 Paying Members, $15,000 a Month, and Why an 18.5M-Download Podcast Hides Ad Revenue but Publishes Stats
Reader

I heard there's a podcast that hides its ad revenue but publishes its falling downloads. Why disclose it that way?

That choice is the show’s business design, laid out in plain sight.

Let’s separate the numbers it publishes from the ones it keeps back.

What you'll learn
  • Annual downloads from 2018 to 2023, as listed on the official stats page
  • How 4,457 paying members become a verifiable floor
  • Why ads are capped at two 60-second slots per episode
  • What membership income means when downloads drop about 33%
  • The limit of what can be checked: ad, Patreon, and merch revenue never appear

Darknet Diaries, a podcast telling true stories of cybercrime, earns just under $15,000 a month from 4,457 paying members.

Host Jack Rhysider disclosed the figure himself in a Supercast interview.

What makes the case genuinely unusual is the design of its disclosure.

Advertising is supposedly the main revenue source for audio media. Rhysider caps it at two 60-second slots per episode, and he doesn’t publish the amount.

Instead, the site hosts a permanent stats page with annual downloads. That includes the latest figures, showing a drop of roughly a third from the peak.

He isn’t revealing everything, and he isn’t hiding everything.

He publishes only the verifiable floor, members times price. That dividing line is the substance of this case.

The official stats page doesn’t end on an upswing

The show launched on September 1, 2017. Annual downloads on the official stats page, which the host publishes as a daily-updated tally, run as follows.

YearAnnual downloads
20181,257,175
20198,286,847
202015,263,255
202122,904,867
202227,677,785 (peak)
202318,506,990 (down ~33% year over year)

The catalog stands at 178 episodes plus 10 bonus episodes and 165 hours of audio. That’s 1,761,504 words of script, which the host equates to 23 novels.

The start wasn’t glamorous.

  1. Three months on episode one

    Initial traffic amounted to "seven clicks a day" from his existing blog plus a couple thousand Twitter followers.

  2. Quitting the day job at six months

    He says it took about a year before the audience was large enough to monetize.

  3. The first 40 or so episodes, alone

    He made them entirely by himself.

  4. A hub-and-spoke setup

    He then brought in freelance editors, producers, sound designers, and writers. Ownership and the voice remain his alone.

Membership becomes a floor anyone can recompute

Paying members buy an ad-free feed, bonus episodes (six at the time of the interview), a Discord community, stickers, and merch discounts.

The point worth pausing on: the core content stays free and unchanged.

The 4,457 members are paying for the show’s survival and a more comfortable listen, rather than for information.

Fan-funded revenue captures only a few percent of the audience. In exchange, it ignores the ad market and accumulates in a form anyone can recompute: members times price.

On a ladder of subscription-funded media, the rungs read like this.

A newsletter that stalled at $13 MRR after going paid. Extra Points at $4,300 a month when it sold. Darknet Diaries at just under $15,000 a month. The Lab at $609K a year.

Audio or text, the free-core-plus-member-perks structure climbs the same steps.

Advertising, by contrast, is deliberately constrained.

The two-slot, 60-second cap is a design decision to protect the listening experience.

About the numbers

Ad revenue is undisclosed. There's also Patreon and Shopify merchandise, with those amounts undisclosed as well. The only figure this article can treat as monthly revenue is the disclosed $15,000 in memberships.

A 33% download drop, published anyway

From the 2022 peak of 27.68 million downloads, 2023 fell about 33% to 18.51 million.

Continuing to publish through the decline says more about the show’s disclosure posture than any of the growth years do.

Public information can’t separate the external factors, such as industry-wide ad pricing or changes in how platforms count.

One thing is legible, though: ad revenue tied to listener numbers absorbs this volatility in full.

This is exactly the moment a membership floor matters.

Downloads can fall by a third, and unless the 4,457 members cancel, the $15,000 remains.

Most customers of Transistor, the podcast hosting SaaS that reached $1M ARR, run shows nowhere near Darknet Diaries’ scale.

What carries over on the show side isn’t waiting for ad-worthy scale. It’s standing up membership revenue first, which works from a few hundred people.

“I won’t disclose income. I’ll disclose all the stats.”

Rhysider draws the line himself.

“I don’t want to be super transparent about how much income I have, I have no problem being super transparent about the stats on my show.”

On why he publishes at all: “I don’t know why people hide from stats so much.” He credits the transparency of creators like Pat Flynn who share income breakdowns.

On keeping ads to two slots: “I don’t want to overdo it. I don’t like to give people a sour taste.”

He goes as far as saying his goal is “to eventually get rid of ads altogether and just be 100% listener-supported.”

That makes membership income the progress gauge for the transition.

Even with amounts hidden, continuously publishing verifiable metrics like member counts and downloads is enough to sustain a media outlet’s credibility and its ad sales.

Ad, Patreon, and merch revenue never appear

The line the host drew is also the limit of what can be checked.

What we couldn't confirm

With ad, Patreon, and merch revenue undisclosed, the total scale of the Darknet Diaries business can't be verified here. The figure of just under $15,000 a month measures only the floor, the 4,457 members. How far the two-slot, 60-second ad limit props up ad rates is also invisible from outside.

The show side has premises of its own.

The stamina to spend three months on a first episode and the feel for the subject belong to this host. Production is outsourced to a freelance network, but the curation and the voice have no substitute.

Exposure on the order of 20 million annual downloads was also reachable because cybercrime is a niche in the English-speaking market.

So this case says nothing about the ceiling for the same design in a smaller language sphere.

Sources

If this one impressed you

Similar cases

Sources

This article summarizes and analyzes the public sources above. Please refer to the primary sources for details.
You may freely quote or republish this article in news media, blogs, or AI answers, provided you credit "Small Start (small-start.com)" and link to this page. No prior permission is needed. Reprint & quotation policy →
Found this useful? Share it
Share on X