Operating

Hiyoko's Handmade Journal: ¥167,200 in year one, and zero sales on minne

A Japanese hobby blog published its full first year of handmade sales: 58 items listed, 46 sold, ¥167,200 in revenue. Every one of those 46 sales came from Mercari, while minne produced nothing for almost a year. Cost of goods fell from 75% to 55%.

Hiyoko's Handmade Journal: ¥167,200 in year one, and zero sales on minne
Reader

I always assumed handmade goods sell on handmade marketplaces like minne or Creema. In a real ledger, where do they actually sell?

This ledger answers that more clearly than you’d expect.

What you'll learn
  • Month-by-month listings, sales and revenue for a first-year side project
  • Why all 46 sales came from Mercari while minne moved nothing
  • What the first ¥9,800 Creema sale says about price bands on each shelf
  • How counting his own hours took the cost ratio from 75% to 55%
  • The listing count the seller regrets, and why the reports stop at month thirteen

¥167,200 over twelve months.

That’s the total first-year revenue from handmade sales published by a personal Japanese blog called Hiyoko’s Handmade Journal.

The reason to record it is the breakdown, not the size.

Fifty-eight items were listed over the year and 46 of them sold. All 46 sold on Mercari, a general-purpose flea market app.

The seller was also listing on minne, the marketplace best known in Japan for handmade goods. For almost a year, nothing moved there at all.

The received wisdom that handmade goods sell on handmade marketplaces doesn’t hold in this ledger.

Neither does the expected sequence where a maker builds a track record by moving onto the specialist shelf.

46 items sold, ¥167,200 earned

The reports treat August 2023 as month one, which puts month twelve in July 2024.

The seller holds a salaried job. He builds wooden goods with LEDs embedded in them as an extension of a DIY hobby, listing them mainly on Mercari.

Month (calendar)ListedSoldRevenue
Month 1 (Aug 2023)22¥6,400
Month 2 (Sep)21¥3,800
Month 3 (Oct)22¥7,000
Month 4 (Nov)43¥12,500
Month 5 (Dec)33¥11,000
Month 6 (Jan 2024)33¥10,500
Month 7 (Feb)44¥13,000
Month 8 (Mar)64¥13,500
Month 9 (Apr)86¥21,000
Month 10 (May)86¥25,000
Month 11 (Jun)75¥20,500
Month 12 (Jul)97¥23,000
Month 13 (Aug)86¥27,000

Twelve months total ¥167,200 across 46 sales and 58 listings. Average selling prices land between ¥3,200 and ¥4,167.

Month nine broke ¥20,000 for the first time at ¥21,000, and the line held near that level afterwards.

The reporting stops at month thirteen, at ¥27,000 for the month and ¥194,200 cumulative.

About the numbers

That's as far as the figures go. Whether sales continued past month fourteen hasn't been published.

The track record was built outside the handmade market

Summing up the first year, the seller described the split bluntly: most of the revenue is Mercari, or rather all of it is Mercari.

On minne, the note reads, nothing has sold yet.

The listings existed. For nearly a year, they drew no orders.

Month thirteen changed that. An item listed on Creema sold within roughly a month, and it went for ¥9,800, over ¥10,000 with shipping.

That single sale produced the best month in the record at ¥27,000.

The seller reads it as a buyer preference. Creema shoppers may be more willing to pay for added value such as function or a sense of occasion.

The dividing line is price band, more than taste

Our reading differs. The dividing line looks less like taste and more like price band.

The 46 items that moved on Mercari sat in the ¥3,000s and ¥4,000s. The seller writes plainly that high-priced items have a ceiling there, and that pushing above roughly ¥4,000 is hard.

The first Creema sale cleared more than twice that ceiling at ¥9,800.

Same maker, same family of products, and the price doubled the moment the shelf changed.

Blaming the silence on minne on product quality is premature.

Each shelf simply clears a different price band.

Cost of goods went from 75% to 55%, through his own hours

The most informative number in this ledger isn’t the revenue curve. It’s the cost ratio.

The month-seven report lines up three figures: 75% at the start, 62% the previous month, 55% that month.

The lever wasn’t cheaper materials but fewer labor hours, which the seller describes as cutting labor cost through process reduction. So his personal working time is booked into cost of goods.

A seller running ¥13,000 months who still prices his own hours is unusual.

Without splitting that ¥13,000 into materials and effort, there’s no way to see what one saved hour is worth in money.

The seller can say that paying more for a part is fine when it makes assembly easier, simpler and faster. He can say it because this accounting puts component cost and labor hours on the same scale.

About the cost ratio

The cost ratio was disclosed only once, at month seven, so where it landed by the end of year one is unknown. Profit in yen is never published either. The month-two report carries a title about a cost ratio over 70% and calls that stretch hellish, which says plainly that the early months left almost nothing behind.

The regret is not about slow sales

In the year-one summary, the seller’s biggest regret is the listing count, more than the order count.

He wishes he’d listed more, given that listings and sales move together and should have been the top priority.

Fifty-eight items across twelve months averages 4.8 per month.

Editors

This part is our own inference. Listings and sales tracked each other because impressions grew, not because inventory did.

On a marketplace where every item opens its own product page, the number of pieces is the number of doors.

Months nine and ten, the only two with eight or more listings, are the two strongest sales months of the year.

What interrupted that flow was the next move.

According to the month-thirteen report, preparing a bid for a minne feature slot consumed time, and listings dropped.

What didn't work
  • Listings on minne drew no orders for nearly a year
  • The minne feature slot, which the seller called a shortcut, had produced no result as of month thirteen
  • Preparing for the feature ate into the listing count that had been moving sales

The targeted shelf delivered nothing, while the unplanned Creema listing produced the best month on record.

The gap against the original expectation is worth keeping too. Looking back at himself a year earlier, the seller recalls assuming ¥200,000 a month was coming.

A full year of sales didn’t reach one month of that target.

He also takes a hard view of the market. He estimates that the number of makers has roughly quadrupled in recent years, while minne’s transaction volume declines and Creema holds flat.

That’s his own observation, with no primary data attached to the post.

Three cases on the same shelf, orders of magnitude apart

Lining handmade cases up by revenue shows where this ledger sits.

Against ¥13,933 a month here, there’s an eight-year accessory maker who reworked ¥600 pricing and reached ¥200,000 to ¥500,000 a month.

There’s a former designer at ¥550,000 a month with a peak of ¥1,000,000, selling mainly on minne.

And there’s a Creema-centered maker who put ¥50,000 of sales proceeds entirely into ads and reached ¥2,000,000 a month.

All three of the larger cases run photography, pricing or advertising with the same weight they give to making the product.

The ¥167,200 went into tools and materials, and the reports stop at month thirteen

This is a salaried worker’s side project, bounded by whatever free hours exist.

On the cash side, the seller writes that it all went into new tools and materials. So ¥167,200 didn’t land as disposable income.

The cost ratio was disclosed once, at month seven, and profit in yen never appears.

And the reporting stops at month thirteen.

What these numbers look like eighteen or twenty-four months in can’t be answered from this source.

If this one impressed you

Similar cases

You may freely quote or republish this article in news media, blogs, or AI answers, provided you credit "Small Start (small-start.com)" and link to this page. No prior permission is needed. Reprint & quotation policy →
Found this useful? Share it
Share on X